Anything Worth Doing- A Review

Anything Worth Doing

anything worth doing

A good book ought to make you think. A really good book ought to make you think hard.

If making you think was its only positive feature, Anything Worth Doing: A True Story of Adventure, Friendship, and Tragedy on the Last of the West’s Great Rivers (by Jo Deurbrouck, Sundog Book Publishing, 198 pages, $15.00) would have hit the bullseye. But this book goes way past that.

Clancy Reece helped pioneer whitewater recreation in Idaho in the early 1970s. Jon Barker was his protege. Together they have some tremendous adventures, the biggest of which was to successfully float Idaho’s Salmon River from source to sea. They used a small, handmade dory as their vessel. “Anything worth doing is worth overdoing.” It’s their motto.

“Wilderness raft guides of the 70s and 80s were often, like Clancy Reece, lovers of freedom with a healthy distrust of rules. They were less often looking for employment when they stumbled into guiding than a solution to what, for each, had been a lifelong problem: how to fit into or somehow hide out from the increasingly urban, increasingly fast-paced latter 20th century. Many felt like they should have been born into a time with more elbow-room, a time in which a man could build a good life from raw materials and honest sweat…”

So we a pair of have what society might call “river bums,” living life on their own terms, the closest of friends, poor in terms of dollars, wealthy in terms of experience. They cook up a hare-brained scheme- to run the Salmon River at peak flood, all the way across Idaho, in a single 24 hour period. The river, running at 96,000 CFS, finally flips the dory near the end of the trip. Reece, not wearing a wetsuit, succumbs to hypothermia. All stories followed long enough have death at the end.

Deurbrouck writes with an almost-startling clarity. There are times during the read when you will almost find yourself clenching the gunwales. The book almost forces you to turn the next page, a hard to put down once you decide to open it. It ought to be required reading for all whitewater paddlers.

After reading it I found myself contemplating, “What’s the best way to live your life?” “What’s the best way to end it?” There are worse ways to die than with your boots on.

Anything Worth Doing is undoubtedly a true story of adventure and friendship. Whether it’s a tragedy as well is something the reader will have to decide for himself.

John Kumiski
http://www.spottedtail.com

All content in this blog, including writing and photos, copyright John Kumiski 2012. All rights are reserved.

Share
|



Book Review- Knowing Bass

Knowing Bass- The Scientific Approach to Catching More Fish by Keith Jones, Ph.D.; hardcover, 298 pages, Lyons Press, 2002 (released as a paperback in 2005).

Knowing Bass has been sitting on my bookshelf for years. Desperation for something to read made me finally crack it. I was a moron to not read it sooner. This book is wonderful.

Dr. Jones, whose research brought you Power Bait and Gulp, studies fish with religious zealotry. Every page explodes with his passion for the subject. If you have any background in the sciences and you have any interest in fish and fishing, you will find this book lively and readable, hard to put down, even.

Disclaimer- If you have a science phobia you’ll hate it.

Bass are pretty far down the list of my interests in fishing. In spite of that this book fascinated me. For example, I always knew fish were capable of learning. It never occurred to me that anyone had measured the speed at which different species learn. According to the study cited in the book, largemouth bass are pretty dumb compared to striped bass and carp.

Dr. Jones goes into great detail about the sensory system of the bass and how the fish uses that system to find food and avoid danger. Adult bass are hard-wired to prefer minnow prey of three to four inches long- darker on the back, lighter on the bottom. They can learn to prefer other things and are always opportunistic, but they come “out-of-the-box” with a preference for small fish.

In spite of the fact they are primarily sight feeders, bass have smells and tastes they like a great deal, and others they dislike tremendously. They can detect minute vibrations in the water. Some attract them, other scare them badly.

Anyone who fishes much knows the water temperature is very important to whatever species you’re targeting. The pH of the water, something most fishermen never even consider, is almost as important as the temperature to a bass.

Do fish feel pain? I’ve written a blog about my feelings on this. Dr. Jones pretty much validates everything I had to say about the topic and then some.

The book goes on in this same vein. It is very thorough.

This book is not an instructional tome on how to fish for bass. Beginning fishermen (or those with science phobias) may not get much out of it. It won’t tell you which lures to use in what circumstances. If that’s what you want, look elsewhere. There are plenty of instructional bass fishing books.

But, if you want to understand how the environment affects the individual fish, if you want to better understand how the fish responds to various stimuli, if you want to get a better feel for what the fish might be doing in any given situation, then this is a great book. Regardless of what kind of fish are your favorites, the book offers great insights into how they work. It’s going into my reference library- I’m sure I’ll be reading it again.

John Kumiski

Home- Spotted Tail Outdoors and Travel


Share
|



 

Book Review- Let Them Paddle

Let Them Paddle: Coming of Age on the Water, by Alan S. Kesselheim, paperback, 336 pages, Fulcrum Publishing, $19.95, is part coming-of-age story, part adventure story, part ecology primer, part family history, richly seasoned with personal philosophy. A husband and wife conceive their first child while on a cross-continental wilderness canoe trip across Canada. Their two subsequent children likewise accompany them in utero on lengthy river trips.

When each child comes into their early teens, the family takes a paddling trip to that child’s river of record. The story starts on the Kazan, a 550 mile long river interspersed with large lakes, that flows into Hudson Bay. The youngest member of the expedition is only nine years old. They deal with rapids, headwinds, weather, insects, polar bears, their own doubts and fears, and more. It makes a riveting adventure story.
“We are in deep, hundreds of miles from anywhere civilized, having scratched our way across trackless space. We are utterly alone, and feel that way. Isolation is too small a word for this. An unequivocal embrace of humility is the only possible response.”

River number two is the Yellowstone. It’s not the same as when Lewis and Clark came through. In spite of that I find myself considering paddling it myself.
They go swimming. “The river mauls us, pulls us under, slaps water in our faces. On top of the waves, we catch glimpses of each other, grin like fools. Then we slide into the trough and disappear. The bulges of boulders go under us, sometimes bumping our butts. The current momentarily keeps us in the backwash of holes, twisting and pulling. Through with the thrill ride, we stroke hard to regain the boats.”

River number three is the Rio Bravo, along the Texas-Mexican border, apparently as remote an area as you’ll find in the lower 48. Again, I found myself thinking, “I want to do this myself.”
“The only real rapid in Mariscal Canyon is called the Tight Squeeze… It’s best when the river does the work for you. Lined up on the outside edge of the passage, Sawyer and I hardly have to maneuver. We draw away from the rock with current piling into it and blast through clean, then pivot into an eddy behind a rock the size of a one car garage.”

On one hand I thought the Kesselheims were crazy for bringing their kids on a wilderness expedition like the one in Canada. OhmyGod, what if something happened? On the other hand you can’t help but have the utmost respect for them. How lucky were those kids to have parents who would take them on such adventures? They’re an American family that’s not dysfunctional!

To be nitpicky, I wasn’t crazy about the cover (although the muscle development, especially in the females, was impressive). But the writing occaisionally dabbles with lyricism, and the storyline is first rate.

I want to meet the Kesselheims. I want to paddle with them. Heck, I want them to adopt me.

If you like to paddle, if you love wild places, if you enjoy true life adventure stories, you have to read this outstanding book. It has my highest recommendation.

John Kumiski
http://www.spottedtail.comĀ 

Share
|



 

Tiggie: The Lure and Lore of Commercial Fishing in New England- A Review

Raised in Chelsea, Masachusetts, Tiggie Peluso could have easily chosen a life of crime. His father was a bookie for the Mob, so he certainly had the opportunity. But no, Tiggie chose to move to Cape Cod and earn a hard, honest living as a commercial fisherman.

Tiggie: The Lure and Lore of Commercial Fishing in New England, by Sandy Macfarlane (paperback, 292 pp, iUniverse Star, $22.95), opens a window into the obscure world of commercial fishing as practiced on the Cape in the 1940s, 50s, and 60s. Macfarlane spent months interviewing Tiggie, who shared with her what a difficult enterprise earning a living from the sea was. There were no electronics. Navigation was by compass, weather was read by observing the sky, fishing spots located with a sounding lead covered in grease or wax. Tiggie survived storms, accidents, some of his friend’s drownings and suicides, his own troubled relationships with women, his struggles to make ends meet.

It would be easy to romanticize a book like this. To her credit, Macfarlane doesn’t. The book is authentic, some passages almost raw. There’s humor, too. It’s a good read.

Tiggie was the first person to become a freshwater fishing guide on the Cape, which I found particularly interesting.

Tiggie won’t be for everyone, and it won’t win a Pulitzer Prize. But to those who have a love of fishing, or an interest in Cape Cod, it’s fascinating stuff.

John Kumiski

Home- Spotted Tail Outdoors and Travel

Share

A New Catfish Fishing Book- The Catfish Hunters

 

the catfish hunters

The Catfish Hunters- Techniques, Science, and Personal Bests, by Jake Bussolini and Mac Byrum. Author House, 2011, paperback, 311 pages, $18.00

OK, so I’m not a catfisherman. And when I saw the cover of this new catfish fishing book my thought was, “You must be kidding me.” The cover photo is terrible, and the price isn’t even on the book.

In the book there are lots of mistakes in spelling and grammar. It does not have an index.

Having gotten all the negatives out of the way, The Catfish Hunters is a darned good book if you have any interest in catfish at all, especially channel cats, flatheads, and blue cats. For starters, the authors have compared detailed catch records to predictions made by the Solunar Tables. Their conclusion? Flipping a coin is more accurate at predicting fish behavior. I agree completely with their final take on that subject- the best time to go fishing is whenever you can.

They also take a hard look at best times of the day to fish. Morning and evening have traditionally been viewed as the best times to fish. Bussolini and Byrum shoot that long-standing myth down, again by using years worth of detailed catch records.

They take a look at catch and release fishing. Using university studies the authors suggest that C&R results in “hook avoidance” by fish, resulting in less healthy fish and poorer quality fishing. It’s an interesting idea that’s bound to raise some controversy in angling circles.

They examine tackle and rigging for cats. They look at boats and how to rig them for the most efficient catfishing. They like using electronics and have many screen shots showing what the bait schools and catfish look like, so when you’re out on the water you know what you’re looking at, having seen it before in these pages. It’s a very nice addition.

One of the techniques they like best is trolling with multiple rods, some of which are rigged with planing boards. They run eight lines while doing this, like offshore anglers after dolphin or billfish.

They look at baits. One of their favorites are chunks of boneless chicken breast marinated overnight in garlic powder. They certainly use more traditional baits such as live and cut baitfish, stink baits, earthworms, and crawfish. They didn’t mention hot dogs!

They discuss safety while on the water, a subject dear to my heart.

The book also covers other fishing techniques than trolling, handling cats, using topographic maps (remember those?), the effect of changing seasons on cats, and more. It ends with detailed discussions about fishing specific bodies of water, including Monticello Lake, Lake Wateree, Lake Norman, the Santee-Cooper Lakes, and several others.

All in all it’s a fascinating, well researched book, and even with the errors still very readable. For anyone interested in fishing for catfish, or any student of angling, The Catfish Hunters is a book well worth reading.

John Kumiski

 

Share
|